Average rating includes incentivized reviews Original

Tomato, Tomahto

A dusty red nail polish with dirty yellow undertones.


Original Nail Polish Frequently Asked Questions:

  • Yes, essie Original nail polish is a vegan formula that contains no animal-derived ingredients.

Discover essie's original professional nail polish

As the color authority since 1981, all essie original nail polishes offer vivid, streak-free color. Get saturated payoff and shine in every coat with our billion pigment formula and patented camel-stem brush for precise, controlled application.

 

Find your perfect shade, with 1 bottle sold every 5 seconds.

 

 


Color with a Reputation

Anyone can create color, but only essie earns a reputation worth keeping. Discover our collection of instantly recognized, impossible-to-imitate shades that always make a statement.

BestSellingReds763x44015x

 

Best-Selling
Red Nail Polish

 

Explore our full range of must-have reds from sheer to bold:

She's Pampered
Not Red-Y For Bed
Forever Yummy
Bordeaux
Berry Naughty
Wicked

 

SHOP REDS SHADES

 

Master a salon-quality nail look

1. Base Coat

Apply 1 coat to bare nails to prime for color while strengthening.

2. Color

Apply 2 coats for optimal opacity.

3. Top Coat

Apply 1 coat for up to 7-day wear.

Shop your essential essie routine

 "essie original color is iconic. I love the brush, the hundreds of colors to choose from, and the fact that it was my first favorite." - Rita Remark, essie Global Brand Ambassador

Similar shades

reviews

rating snapshot

Select a row below to filter reviews.
13 reviews with 5 stars.
1 review with 4 stars.
0 reviews with 3 stars.
0 reviews with 2 stars.
0 reviews with 1 star.

overall rating

4.9

Review this Product

Select to rate the item with 1 star. This action will open submission form.
Select to rate the item with 2 stars. This action will open submission form.
Select to rate the item with 3 stars. This action will open submission form.
Select to rate the item with 4 stars. This action will open submission form.
Select to rate the item with 5 stars. This action will open submission form.
Adding a review will require a valid email for verification

Filter Reviews

  • color
  • red
  • satisfaction
  • quality
  • appearance
  • enjoyment
  • stains
  • wait time
1 to 8 of 14 reviews .
1 – 8 of 14 reviews

Such a cute color

5 months ago
I received this product for free to review. I love this brand of nail polish. It’s glides on smooth and the polish isn’t sticky or clumpy. The top takes a little more effort to open which is a plus because I have toddlers. This color is also so cute.
  • Review photo 1.
helpful?

Tomato tomahto

6 months ago
Loved this color and how it complimented my skin tone. Essie is a quality brand that’s reasonably priced and I love purchasing from this brand. I have a whole collection from them and love that I’ve added this color to it.
helpful?

Can't go wrong with Essie

6 months ago
This collection is so pretty. The names and the shades are so unique. Love the staying power of essie nail polish. I'll be sure to be on the lookout for more shades. I highly recommend.
helpful?

Love this color

6 months ago
I love the brand and the quality. Very good overall. The smell is pretty strong but all nail polish smells similar. Some stronger than other. Dries fast. Love the color as well. Something between red and orange
helpful?

🍅🍅

6 months ago
The bottle is so nice honestly. And the color is such a fun red. It was really easy to apply but took a minute to dry. It lasted quite awhile and stained my nails a little.
helpful?

A timeless red!

7 months ago
Essie has this shade called "Tomato, Tomahto" in their Gourmet Grocery collection and it is the definition of a timeless red! I just love the shade! This is a red that never goes out of style!
helpful?

really nice

7 months ago
I really liked the color because it's a true red with a touch of warmth that makes it look great on warm and neutral skin tones. It has a slightly soft, orangey undertone. It has excellent pigmentation; to achieve an even tone, I applied three coats using the primer and quick-drying formula from the same brand.
helpful?

Tomato Tomahto

7 months ago
A juicy, bold red with warm undertones. This shade is giving fresh farmers market tomatoes, cozy kitchen vibes, and effortless all in one swipe. It’s a classic essie high-shine finish without streaks. Whether you’re going for clean-girl nails, a soft fall manicure, or a statement red that isn’t overpowering, tomahto does it all.
helpful?
1 – 8 of 14 reviews

rating snapshot

Select a row below to filter reviews.
13 reviews with 5 stars.
1 review with 4 stars.
0 reviews with 3 stars.
0 reviews with 2 stars.
0 reviews with 1 star.

overall rating

4.9

Review this Product

Select to rate the item with 1 star. This action will open submission form.
Select to rate the item with 2 stars. This action will open submission form.
Select to rate the item with 3 stars. This action will open submission form.
Select to rate the item with 4 stars. This action will open submission form.
Select to rate the item with 5 stars. This action will open submission form.
Adding a review will require a valid email for verification

Filter Reviews

  • color
  • red
  • satisfaction
  • quality
  • appearance
  • enjoyment
  • stains
  • wait time
9 to 14 of 14 reviews .
9 – 14 of 14 reviews

Long-lasting and highly pigmented tomato red nail

7 months ago
The Essie Tomato, Tomahto Nail Lacquer is part of their Gourmet Grocery Salon-Quality Nail Polish Collection. This polish features a vibrant, juicy tomato red hue with warm yellow undertones. Application is a breeze thanks to the easy glide brush, and it delivers full coverage without staining the nails. Plus, the high-quality, streak-free formula ensures a flawless finish every time! ✨
  • Review photo 1.
  • Review photo 2.
  • Review photo 3.
  • Review photo 4.
helpful?

Not bad

7 months ago
It’s not bad, down last long but what do I expect it’s nail polish not gel nor fake nails so but overall it’s not bad it’s a cute color and the size and build is fine.
  • Review photo 1.
helpful?

Go and try it

8 months ago
Love it, the color is so cute and easy to used it. I like it because you don’t need to apply to much because it cover a lot in the nail. And it dry out pretty quickly.
helpful?

Beautiful Color!

8 months ago
I’m really liking this tomato red shade , its the perfect shade of red . The red is darker shade to me , but I think it’s a perfect shade. I love Essie polish it does last awhile without chipping off. I did have to put 2 coats of polish to achieve the shade I wanted , but I do love this polish and can’t wait to try other shades .
helpful?

Love

8 months ago
Such a fun tomato red color. Essie is always a 10/10. Lasts a long time. Hardens my nails perfectly so they don’t crack. This red just reminds me of the spring. Can’t wait to use it way more
helpful?

Elf nail polish

8 months ago
So nice packaging so nice product the color is so nature the bottle is so beautiful it lasts longtime on my nail the consistency is so beautiful good product
helpful?
9 – 14 of 14 reviews